![wp-1451210187604 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451210187604.jpg?w=863)
I’ve tried to write a spoiler-free review but there are plot points and character descriptions in what follows so if you really really don’t want any pre-knowledge of the movie before seeing it then I’ll just say that I absolutely loved it. Now go see it then come back and read this afterwards and tell me what you think. Otherwise , read on Macduff…
I recently re-watched The Phantom Menace (well, the anti-cheese fanboy edit on YouTube – can anyone sit through the full movie?) and by midway through the opening crawl (taxation of trade routes is in dispute FFS) I was already bored.
![wp-1451210662953 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451210662953.jpg?w=863)
So compared to any of George Lucas’s trilogy of prequels The Force Awakens is Citizen Kane and any of my
criticism of Force Awakens should be taken with this in mind.
On that note let’s get my moans out of the way first. The biggest (SPOILER ALERT) is that it’s basically a remake of the original Star Wars movie.
I realise this has been done for the same reason that Marvel continually re-hashes origin stories (because the studios want to draw in new viewers whilst not alienating existing devotees and what better way than by re-imagining the story that got everyone hooked in the first instance), it just felt a wee bit lazy.
My second bugbear is that you have to forget or ignore some pretty big plotlines from the original films. Mainly that The Return of the Jedi wrapped up the original tale with a big bow but also that the storm troopers were a clone army cast in the image of Jango Fett.
![wp-1451210915314 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451210915314.jpg?w=863)
Now I’m sure the sequels will fill in the backstory and explain how these came to be but it felt a little unsatisfactory to my fanboy sensibilities that I now need to accept that the Empire is as dominant as ever and the resistance even further under the heel.
I also don’t think that some of the newer characters are particularly well drawn.
![wp-1451211039987 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451211039987.jpg?w=863)
Screen writer, scion of Hollywood royalty and regular contributor to the Youtube movie crit channel “Trailers From Hell” Max Landis (above) has accused one of the main protagonists Rey of being a Mary Sue character –
![wp-1451211316145 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451211316145.png?w=863)
or in other words that’s she’s a poorly developed result of the author’s wish-fulfillment . On reflection it’s an argument I agree with. For example she can fix (and fly) the Millennium Falcon without any prior knowledge. Compare that with the utterly butterfingered incompetence of the pre-enlightenment Luke in the original and you’ll get my drift. Having said that it’s not such a big deal that it in any way spoils the film. And on the positive side it’s very heartening to see a female role that’s so pivotal. I just think maybe JJ Abram’s idea of a strong female character was a bit too literal.
Also, along with other Abrams’ movies (think Star Trek, Super Eight, MI3) to me the film is destined to be very fondly remembered whilst never becoming a classic. BUT as I’ve already mentioned, after the disastrous trilogy of prequels it’s more than enough to be going on with.
That’s it on the moaning front (promise) because the film is such enormous fun I can forgive it any number of flaws. It looks like a classic Star Wars film with desert planet and snow planet scenes, giant space stations, death rays, light sabers and silly bar scenes.
Also I saw the film in 3G but I don’t think that added much except a sense of vertigo in some of the vertiginous scenes involving Rey.
The tie-fighter dog-fight scenes definitely benefit from being staged near the planet surface rather than in outer-space as it gives a greater feeling of speed and peril.
![wp-1451212801990 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451212801990.png?w=863)
The movie takes its cue from Guardians of the Galaxy and even Firefly and recaptures the spirit of the original film as a western in outer space. The movie also references snow scenes of Christopher Nolan’s Inception.
There’s thankfully more emphasis on physical SFX but where used the CGI is excellent.
![wp-1451215370598 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451215370598.jpg?w=863)
I loved the mix of sci-fi tech and old artefacts like the wooden box the light saber is kept in. I loved the nods to the originals like Luke’s battle-ball being sat on by Finn, the old hologram chess set coming back to life and of course the re-animated Millennium Falcon and the superannuated original cast.
![wp-1451213532637 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451213532637.jpg?w=863)
The music was spot on (someone has been watching Where Eagles Dare as the rousing ascending musical motif of Ron Goodwin’s music is very much in evidence – no complaints from me as that is my all time favorite adventure theme)
The film is studded throughout with stunning locations – none more so than
Skellig Michael which looks so astonishing I’ve added it to my list other reasons for doing a tour of Ireland as soon as possible
![wp-1451213446079 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451213446079.jpg?w=863)
The film is packed full of stunning set pieces and jaw-dropping design work. The Yanick Dusseault designed rally of the Empire storm troopers
![wp-1451214354608 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451214354608.jpg?w=863)
takes its blueprint from Nazi rallys at the 1936 Olympics for example is a masterpiece.
![wp-1451214199811 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451214199811.jpg?w=863)
And the wreckage of the Imperial star destroyer is awe-inspiring.
![wp-1451214979058 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451214979058.jpg?w=863)
Check out this Buzzfeed article for more on the concept art for the movie.
My inner geek is desperately seeking justification to buy the concept-art book but hasn’t yet managed to come up with a convincing argument
Some copacetic new characters are introduced. I thought Adam Driver was outstanding giving real emotion to what could have been a pretty two-dimensional character.
![wp-1451215015144 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451215015144.jpg?w=863)
And I loved the bro-mance between Oscar Isaac and John Boyega.
![wp-1451215043174 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451215043174.jpg?w=863)
The ‘droid BB8 of course becomes the new must have Christmas figure
![wp-1451215229343 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451215229343.jpg?w=863)
I loved the way the older characters are reintroduced and the script thankfully brings back the humour of the original trilogy. Han Solo’s twinkle is still in his eye and the relationship between Solo and Leia is very well drawn and surprisingly moving.
Harrison Ford and Carrie Fisher are head and shoulders the best thing about the film
![wp-1451215425427 image](https://eatseehearcardiff.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/wp-1451215425427.jpg?w=863)
To sum up then, a film that’s not quite the sum of its parts but what parts they are! Brilliant, stunning fun. Very very enjoyable – and, not to damn with faint praise, a huge relief after the three awful prequels.
The forever saga is back on course – go see it.
Highly recommended